Hockey Jargon

Decoding Plus Minus: The Controversy and Value in Evaluating Hockey Players

Understanding Plus Minus in HockeyHockey is a thrilling and fast-paced sport, filled with talented athletes who score goals and make game-changing plays. One statistic that has been used for years to measure a player’s overall performance is the plus minus stat.

In this article, we will delve into the definition and calculation of plus minus, explore the controversy and limitations surrounding it, and discuss its validity as an indicator of performance in hockey. Additionally, we will highlight some players who have excelled in this area and emphasize the importance of balancing scoring and defensive skills.

By the end of this article, you will have a comprehensive understanding of plus minus and its role in evaluating hockey players. Definition of Plus Minus:

The plus minus stat is a metric used in hockey to measure a player’s impact on the game.

It determines the difference in scoring when a player is on the ice, taking into account goals scored and goals allowed. The concept is simple: if a player is on the ice when their team scores a goal, they receive a +1, and if they are on the ice when the opposing team scores a goal, they receive a -1.

Calculation of Plus Minus:

Calculating the plus minus stat requires keeping track of a player’s ice time and monitoring goals scored and allowed during that time. At the end of a game, the plus minus for each player is tallied, resulting in a numerical value that represents their overall impact on the score.

For example, if a player is on the ice for five goals scored by their team and two goals allowed by their team, their plus minus would be +3 (5-2). Controversy and Limitations of Plus Minus:

While plus minus can provide a general idea of a player’s impact on the game, it is not without controversy and limitations.

One primary concern is the influence of variables beyond a player’s control. For instance, line changes and goalie performance can greatly affect the plus minus stat.

Additionally, superstar players often face tougher opponents and are more likely to be on the ice during critical moments, potentially skewing their plus minus. Furthermore, players on weaker teams may have higher negative values due to their team’s overall struggle to defend and score goals.

Validity of Plus Minus as an Indicator:

The validity of plus minus as an indicator of a player’s performance is a topic of debate among hockey enthusiasts and analysts. While some argue that it is a straightforward measure of a player’s impact, others believe it fails to account for situational factors and defensive contributions that may not be reflected in the plus minus stat.

Despite this controversy, plus minus can still provide a useful overview of a player’s overall success on both ends of the ice. Players with Great Plus Minus Stats:

There have been several players in hockey history who have excelled in the plus minus category, solidifying their reputation as exceptional performers.

One of the greatest examples is Bobby Orr, who holds the record for the highest single-season plus minus with an incredible +124. Orr’s offensive prowess, coupled with his exceptional defensive skills, made him a dominant force on the ice.

Other notable players with outstanding plus minus stats include Nik Lidstrom, a seven-time Norris Trophy winner, and numerous Selke award winners known for their outstanding two-way play. Importance of Balancing Scoring and Defensive Skills:

While plus minus can serve as a simple indicator of a player’s performance, it is crucial to recognize the importance of balancing offensive and defensive abilities.

A player with a high plus minus may excel in scoring goals but may neglect their defensive responsibilities. Similarly, a player with a low plus minus can prioritize defensive duties but may struggle to contribute offensively.

The ideal hockey player combines scoring proficiency with the ability to stop opponents, creating a well-rounded impact on the game. In conclusion, plus minus is a statistical measurement used in hockey to evaluate a player’s overall impact on the game.

While it has its controversies and limitations, plus minus can still provide valuable insights into a player’s performance. It is essential to consider situational factors, defensive contributions, and the balance between offensive and defensive skills when analyzing a player’s plus minus stat.

By understanding and recognizing the nuances surrounding plus minus, fans and analysts can gain a deeper appreciation of a player’s contributions and the complexities of the game of hockey.

Evaluation of Plus Minus

Determining a Good Plus Minus:

When it comes to determining what constitutes a good plus minus stat in hockey, the general rule of thumb is to aim for a rating above zero. A positive plus minus indicates that a player has contributed more goals for their team than they have allowed against, showcasing their ability to make a positive impact on the game.

On the other hand, a negative plus minus suggests that a player’s team has allowed more goals while they were on the ice than they have scored, highlighting potential defensive lapses or struggles in generating offense. While a plus minus above zero is generally viewed as favorable, it is crucial to consider the context in which a player accumulates this statistic.

Factors such as the team’s overall performance, playing time, and the caliber of opponents faced all play a role in interpreting the value of a player’s plus minus. Therefore, it is important to take a deeper dive and compare players within their respective teams and situations to gain a more accurate understanding of their performance.

Comparison of Best Plus Minus Players in the 2018-19 Season:

The 2018-2019 NHL season showcased several players who posted impressive plus minus stats, exemplifying their contributions to their respective teams. One notable player was Ryan O’Reilly of the St. Louis Blues, who finished the season with a remarkable plus minus of +22.

O’Reilly’s strong two-way game and defensive awareness solidified his position as a key contributor, playing a significant role in the Blues’ eventual Stanley Cup victory. Another player who excelled in the plus minus category that season was Mark Giordano of the Calgary Flames.

Giordano recorded a plus minus of +39, earning him the distinction of being the league leader in this category. A true stalwart on both ends of the ice, Giordano’s defensive prowess and ability to generate offense from the blue line propelled the Flames to a successful regular season.

The 2018-2019 season also saw players like Brad Marchand of the Boston Bruins (+25), Patrice Bergeron of the Boston Bruins (+23), and Sean Couturier of the Philadelphia Flyers (+21) shine in the plus minus department. These players demonstrated their ability to contribute at both ends of the ice and played vital roles in their teams’ success.

All-Time Best Plus Minus for Career:

When analyzing the all-time best plus minus in hockey, one name stands out: Rasmus Ristolainen of the Buffalo Sabres. Ristolainen, a Finnish defenseman, currently holds the highest career plus minus rating in NHL history, with an impressive +102.

This remarkable achievement is a testament to his consistency and ability to positively impact the game while on the ice. Ristolainen’s high career plus minus also highlights the importance of considering a player’s longevity and the overall success of their team.

Playing for the Sabres, who have faced their fair share of challenges in recent years, Ristolainen’s ability to maintain a positive plus minus showcases his skill and dedication to his defensive responsibilities. Despite the team’s struggles, he has consistently contributed more goals for than goals against, solidifying his status as a top-tier defenseman.

In conclusion, evaluating plus minus in hockey involves looking beyond the numerical value and considering various factors such as team performance, playing time, and quality of opponents faced. While a positive plus minus generally indicates a player’s ability to make a positive impact on the game, a comprehensive evaluation requires a deeper dive into the context in which the statistic was accumulated.

By comparing players within their respective teams and situations, we gain a more accurate understanding of their contributions. The 2018-19 season showcased players like Ryan O’Reilly and Mark Giordano, who excelled in the plus minus category, while all-time records highlight the achievements of players like Rasmus Ristolainen.

Understanding the intricacies of plus minus allows us to appreciate the complexities of the game and recognize the well-rounded players who excel at both ends of the ice. In conclusion, plus minus is a statistical measure that evaluates a player’s impact on the game by considering goals scored and allowed while they are on the ice.

While controversies and limitations surround this metric, a positive plus minus generally indicates a player’s ability to contribute to their team’s success. By comparing players within their respective teams and situations, we can gain a more accurate understanding of their performance.

The 2018-19 season featured standout players like Ryan O’Reilly and Mark Giordano, while Rasmus Ristolainen holds the all-time career record. Understanding plus minus allows us to appreciate the complexities of the game and recognize well-rounded players who excel at both ends of the ice.

Thus, plus minus remains an important and insightful metric in evaluating player performance in hockey.

Popular Posts